MYSTICAL ASPECT OF EDITH STEIN'S ANTHROPOLOGY: FROM PHENOMENOLOGY TO THOMISM

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15802/ampr.v0i10.87353

Keywords:

Edith Stein, phenomenology, Thomism, mysticism, empathy, intuition, ethical subject

Abstract

The aim of the study is to find mystical elements in Edith Stein's anthropology as a connecting principle between phenomenology and Thomism. Relying on methodological definition of philosophical mystic, as a matching of theological and philosophical doctrines, based upon reflection on experience of ecstatic unity with the Absolute, it was shown that phenomenology is implicitly directed towards research of real structure of immediate experience which in all its limits approaches to mystical experience. Not the mind and not the faith, but will (that directs knowledge to mystical unity of immanent subject and transcendental object in finding the truth) is defining for the mystical character of Stein's creative method. Stein, being a bright representative of phenomenology, gradually disagrees with Husserl at some points: 1. Stein considers the world as an immediate contemplation on the entity that transcends the identity of being and thinking; 2. In her opinion, phenomenology neglects the ontological Absolute. As a result, there is misplace of the Absolute by structural-cognitive aims, that, in its turn, was a reason for amalgamation of onthology and epistemology, according to Stein's views. 3. Stein strives to overcome epistemological rationality and achieve a sphere of philosophical mystic where ontological object and epistemological subject are identical in the act of mystical contemplation. 4. Lack of metaphysical elements in phenomenology leads Stein to Thomism in which she potentially seeks a way out of metaphysical limits and the way which leads to the level of transpersonal states of mind. 5. Stein reproaches transcendentalism in loss of the world and she ignores the changes in Husserl's world outlook, his transcendental turn and genealogy of the trustworthy acquaintance with the world. An empathy, as a model of extrapolation of the principle (of to be get used to the experience of the Other) onto mystical act of overcoming of subject-object opposition of transpersonal content and an intuition, as a movement inside the self, an ability to complete an integral image refusing the subjectivity and bringing back generic, spiritual subject, are considered to be key-constructs of the Edith Stein's evolutionary views development on her way to philosophical mystic. At the same time, mystical does not drop out of the phenomenological series but fills it with new existential meaning. The novelty of the study is in its showing up the productive meaning of philosophical mystics in the creativity of Edith Stein, who enriched contemporary anthropology by metahistorical content of moral and existential meaning on the basis of synthesis of philosophy of mind and Thomistic metaphysics.

Author Biography

J. A. Shabanova, State National Mining University

J. A. Shabanova

References

Gusserl E. Lektsii po fenomenologii vnutrennego soznaniya vremeni. Tom 1. [Lectures on the phenomenology of internal consciousness of time. Vol. 1]. Moscow, Gnozis Publ., 1994. 162 р.

Gusserl E. Nachalo geometrii. Vvedeniye Zh. Derrida [Beginning of geometry. Introduction of Zh. Derrida]. Moscow, Ad Marginem Publ., 1996. pp. 3-27.

Shtayn E. Budova ljudsjkoji osoby [Anthropologya]. Zhovkva, Misioner Publ., 2011. 192 р.

Shtayn E. Vstup do filosofii [Introduction to philosophy]. Zhovkva, Misioner Publ., 2011. 248 р.

Shtayn, E. Shho take ljudyna? [Anthropologya]. Zhovkva, Misioner Publ., 2014. 232 р.

Shtayn E. Nauka Kresta. Issledovaniye o svyatom Khuane de la Kruse [Science of the Cross. Study of the holy Juan de la Cruz]. Moscow, Institut filosofii, teologii i istorii sv. Fomy Publ., 2008. 288 р.

Shtayn E. Chto takoye filosofiya? Razgovor Edmunda Gusserlya i Fomy Akvinskogo [What is philosophy? Conversation of Edmund Gusserl and Thomas Aquinskiy]. Δόξα – Doksa, 2009, issue 14, pp. 372-394.

Beckmann B. Phänomenologie des religiösen Erlebnisses. Religionsphilo-sophische Überlegungen im Anschluß an Adolf Reinach und Edith Stein. Würzburg, Königshausen & Neumann Publ., 2003. 332 р.

Beckmann-Zöller B., Gerl-Falkovitz H.-B. Die unbekannte Edith Stein: Phänomenologie und Sozialphilosophie. Frankfurt am Main, Lang Publ., 2006. 278 р. doi: https://doi.org/10.3726/978-3-653-01234-7

Bejas A. Edith Stein. Von der Phänomenologie zur Mystik. Frankfurt/M, Peter Lang Publ., 1987. 208 р.

Bejas A. Vom Seienden als solchen zum Sinn des Seins. Die Transzendentalien-lehre bei Edith Stein und Thomas von Aquin. Frankfurt/Main, Lang Publ., 1994. 270 p.

Bütow K. Ein wahrhaftiges Leben Edith Stein. Gütersloh, Kiefel Publ, 1999. 47 р.

Crvenka M. Gott und ich. Meditationen zu Texten von Edith Stein. Essen, Plöger Publ., 1993. 96 p.

Crvenka M. Entscheidung für Gott. Die Taufe Edith Steins. Leutesdorf, Johannes Publ., 1991. 48 p.

Edith-Stein-Jahrbuch. Hrsg. im Auftrag des Teresianischen Karmels in Deutschland durch das Internationale Edith-Stein-Institut Würzburg. Band 1. Würzburg, Echter Verlag Publ., 1995. 175 p.

Feldes J. Auf den Spuren Edith Steins durch Köln. Köln, Selbstverlag Publ., 2005. 40 р.

Feldes J. Im Kreuz ist Hoffnung. Der Kreuzweg mit Edith Stein. Speyer, Pilger Publ., 1999. 66 p.

Fetz R.L., Rath M., Schulz P. Studien zur Philosophie von Edith Stein. Internationales Edith-Stein-Symposium Eichstätt 1991. Freiburg-München, Alber Publ., 1993. 370 p.

Heise I. Einfühlung bei Edith Stein. Überraschende Einblicke in die Doktorarbeit einer sensiblen Heiligen. Wien, Selbstverlag Publ., 2005. 80 p.

Henry M. Incarnation: une philosophie de la chair. Paris, Seuil Publ., 2000. 381 p.

Herbstrith W. Edith Stein. Ein Lebensbild in Zeugnissen und Selbst-zeugnissen. Mainz, Grünewald Publ., 1993. 188 р.

Jani A. Edith Steins Denkweg von der Phänomenologie zur Seinsphilosophie. Würzburg, Königshausen & Neumann Publ., 2015. 402 p.

Koch U. Edith Stein. Eine kleine, einfache Wahrheit sagen. Biographischer Roman. Gießen, Brunnen Publ., 2005. 176 р.

Lebech M. The Philosophy of Edith Stein: from phenomenology to metaphysics. Wien, Lang Publ., 2015. 188 p.

Petermeier M. Die religiöse Entwicklung der Edith Stein. Eine Untersuchung zur Korrelation von Lebens - und Glaubensgeschichte. Frankfurt/M., Peter Lang Publ., 1998. 244 p.

Scheler М. Zur Phanomenologie und Theorie der Sympathiegefiihle und von Liebe und Had. Mit einem Anhang iiber den Grund zur Annahme der Existenz des fremden Ich. Halle, Niemeyer Publ., 1913. 158 p.

Stein E. Fenomenologia getynsko-monachijska. Analizy. Wroclaw, TOTEM Publ., 2015. 204 p.

Stein E. Fenomenologia getynsko-monachijska. Zrodla. Wroclaw, Drukarnia Cyfrowa On-line Publ., 2014. 162 p.

Stein E. Kreuzeswissenschaft. Studie über Johannes vom Kreuz. Freiburg, Herder Publ., 2004. 266 p.

Stein E. Potenz und Akt. Studien zu einer Philosophie des Seins. Freiburg, Herder Publ., 2005. 318 p.

Stein E. Was ist Philosophie? Ein Gespräch zwischen Edmund Husserl und Thomas von Aquino. Erkenntnis und Glaube. Freiburg, Herder Publ., 1993. P. 19-48.

Stein E. Zum Problem der Einfühlung. München, Kaffke Publ., 1980. 133 p.

Volek P. Husserl und Thomas von Aquin bei Edith Stein. Nordhausen, Traugott Bautz Publ., 2016. 248 p.

Published

2016-12-22

How to Cite

Shabanova, J. A. (2016). MYSTICAL ASPECT OF EDITH STEIN’S ANTHROPOLOGY: FROM PHENOMENOLOGY TO THOMISM. Anthropological Measurements of Philosophical Research, (10), 107–120. https://doi.org/10.15802/ampr.v0i10.87353

Issue

Section

ANTHROPOLOGICAL PROBLEMS IN THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY