V. O. Patsan


The aim of the article is to define the way of expounding the authenticity of the experience of self-cognition opened by the personalist philosophy of the USA on the horizon of receiving the philosophical tradition established by B. P. Bowne to lay the epistemological foundations for overcoming the impersonalist modes of thought in the philosophical-humanitarian space of North America. At the emergent stage of the historical-philosophical process defined as its post-secular period the topicality of studying American personalism in the indicated aspect of its genesis is predetermined by developing the personalistic inspiration of post-non-classical philosophy into renewing the interaction of philosophical and theological discourses initial for the personalist thought and intended to reunite rationality with its spiritual sources in the course of reflecting the personal mode of being realized on the ground of theism. The further reflection of the meta-ontology of the personhood uncovered by the Scripture and expounded by patristic trinitology presupposes the retrospection of the trajectory of moving towards the Supernatural Revelation paved in the late nineteenth and the first half of twentieth centuries by the attempts of personalizing the ontology, in particular by the “personalized” ontological constructions made in the USA. The methodology of the research is based upon realizing the meta-ontological character of the problem of the personality revealed in the midst of the twentieth century by the prominent Orthodox theologian and philosopher-personalist V. N. Lossky. Taking into consideration the Biblical background of American personalism and its genetic connections with the denominations of Protestantism developed on the North American continent and the branching Protestant theology, the author focuses on both proper philosophical and theological reference points of this personalistic current of philosophizing in the historical-philosophical reconstruction of its genesis oriented towards the meta-ontological dimension of the personality. The scientific novelty of the study consists in initiating the reflection of the way of defining the inner experience of the self as the all-sufficient criterion of cognition which was paved by the personalist thought of the USA in the course of revising the classical rationalist models of the subjectivity and broke the ground for constructing “the personal world” in the space of rational consciousness formed in North America. On the base of analyzing Bowne's revision of Kant's transcendental idealism aimed at the explication of the immediacy of self-experience the author reveals that such argumentation for its cognitive primacy transforms into affirming the mediation of the inner appeal of the human personality to living God by the outer interpersonal experience of rational cognition. The revealed regression to the rationally mediated relationship of the created person with Creator is connected with the restriction of the research for “personal beginning of all speculation” which resulted in the personal metaphysics of B. P. Bowne by the rationalistic tools of the personal self-reflection.  The study proves that it was predetermined by the philosopher's confessional belonging to the Methodist Church detached from patristic Trinitology and Christology forming the arsenal of trinitarian meta-logic intended to expound the personhood as the ultimate principle of being. Conclusions define the resource of Bowne's idea of the “personal interpretation of experience” which inspired the subsequent “personalized” ontological constructions in the personalistic domain established on the North American continent. They form the dialogic space of the personalist philosophy of the USA predetermining the accumulation of its potential in the interaction with other philosophical currents.  Manifesting itself as the personalistic inspiration of the emerging trends of thought this tendency predicts the focus of the further historical-philosophical research of American personalism.


Absolute Personality of God; Supernatural Revelation; personal principle of being; human person; meta-ontology of the personhood; personal metaphysics; self-experience; personal experience of self-cognition

Full Text:



1. Episkop Varnava (Beliaev). Osnovy iskusstva svyatosti: Opyt izlozheniya pravoslavnoy asketiky [The Foundations of Sacred Mastery: An Attempt to Present the Orthodox Asceticism]. Nizhniy Novgorod, Izd. Bratstva vo imia sv. Alexandra Nevskogo Publ., 1998. 242 p.

2. Levinas E. Izbrannoye: Totalnost i beskonechnoye [Favorites: Totality and infinite]. Moscow, Saint Petersburg, Universitetskaya kniga Publ., 2000. 416 p.

3. Liotar Zh.-F. Sostoyaniye postmoderna [The Postmodern Condition]. Mocow, Institut experimentalnoy sotsiologii Publ., 1998. 160 p.

4. Losskiy V.N. Bogoslovskoye ponyatiye chelovecheskoy lichnosti. Bogovideniye [The Theological Concept of the Human Person. Vision of God]. Minsk, Belorusskyi Ekzarkhat – «Kharvest» Publ., 2007. pp. 400-411.

5. Nesmelov V.I. Nauka o cheloveke [The Science of Human Being]. Saint Petersburg, Obschestvo pamyati igumenii Taisii Publ., 2013. 936 p.

6. Okorokov V.B. Transformatsiia zakhidnoievropeiskoi metafizyky (ontolohichnyi zriz). Avtoreferat Dys. [Transformation of Western metaphysics (ontological cut). Author’s Abstract.]. Dnipropetrovsk, 2003. 42 p.

7. Sigov K. Porblema razryva mezhdy ontologiyey i etikoy v sovremennykh ucheniyakh o cheloveke .Pravoslvnoye ucheniye o cheloveke [The problem of the pap between ontology and ethics in the contemporary humanities. The Orthodox doctrine of man]. Moscow, Klin, Sinodalnaya Bogoslovskaya Komissiya – Izdatelstvo «Khristianskaya Zhizn» Publ., 2004. pp. 340-356.

8. Uzlaner D. Vvedeniye v postsekuliarnuyu filosofiyu [Introduction to the post-secular philosophy]. Logos. Postsekuliarnaia filosofia – Logos. Post-secular philosophy, 2011, no. 3 (82), pp. 3-32.

9. Balthasar H.U. von. On the Concept of Person. Communio: International Catholic Review, 1986, no. 13, pp. 18-26.

10. Bartnik C.S. Personalistic Ontology. Personalism. Science. Philosophy. Theology, 2003, no. 5, pp. 68-84.

11. Bengtsson J.O. The Worldview of Personalism: Origins and Early Development. Oxford, Oxford University Press Publ., 2011. 354 p.

12. Bowne B.P. Personalism. Boston, 1908. 354 p.

13. Bowne B.P. Philosophy of Theism. Boston, CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform Publ., 2015. 284 p.

14. Brightman Edgar Sheffield Brightman. Personalism. A History of Philosophical Systems. New York, Philosophical Library Publ., 1950. 343 p.

15. Buford T.O. Classical American Personalism. Available at: (Accessed 9 June 2016).

16. Burrow R. Personalism: A Critical Introduction. St. Louis, Chalice Press Publ., 1999. 328 p.

17. Clark St.R.L. How many Selves make me? Human Being. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press Publ., 1991. pp. 67-92.

18. Deats P., Carol R. The Boston Personalist Tradition in Philosophy, Social Ethics and Theology. Macon, GA, Mercer University Press Publ., 1986. 254 p.

19. Derrida J. Writing and Difference. London, Routledge Publ., 2001. 472 p.

20. Flewelling R.T. Studies in American Personalism. Personalism. Science. Philosophy. Theology, 2004, no. 6, pp. 23-42.

21. Foucault M. Nietzsche, Genealogy, History. Language, Counter-Memory, and Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews. Oxford, Basil Blackwell Publ., 1977. pp. 139-165.

22. Foucault M. The Subject and Power. Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics. Brighton, HarvesterPress Publ., 1982. pp. 208-227.

23. Habermas J. Religion ad Rationality: Essays on Reason, God and Modernity. Cambridge, MA, MIT Press Publ., 2002. 384 p.

24. Hocking W.E. The Meaning of God in Human Experience. Available at: (Accessed 9 June 2016).

25. Gacka B.A. Presentation of Personalism. Personalism, Science, Philosophy, Theology, 2001, no. 1.

26. Knudson A.C. The Philosophy of Personalism. New York, Abington Publ., 1927. 434 p.

27. Mounier E. Révolution personnaliste et communautaire. Available at: (Accessed 9 June 2016).

28. Patsan V.O. (Bishop Eulogius of Novomoskovsk). The Biblical Background of American Personalism. 8th International Scientific and Practical Conference “Science and Society”. London, 2016, pp. 120-132.

29. Post-secular Philosophy: between Philisophy and Theology. London, Routledge Publ., 1998. 392 p.

30. Williams Th.D., Bengtsson J.O. Personalism. Available at: (Accessed 9 June 2016).

GOST Style Citations

  1. Епископ Варнава (Беляев). Основы искусства святости: Опыт изложения православной аскетики: В 4-х т. / Епископ Варнава (Беляев). – Нижний Новгород: Изд. Братства во имя св. кн. Александра Невского,1998. Т.1. – 242 с.
  2. Левинас, Э. Избранное: Тотальность и бесконечное / Э. Левинас. – Москва; Санкт-Питербург : Университетская книга, 2000. – 416 c .
  3. Лиотар, Ж.-Ф. Состояние постмодерна / Ж.-Ф. Лиотар [Пер. с фр. Н. А. Шматко]. – Москва : Институт экспериментальной социологии; Санкт-Питербург : Алетейя, 1998. – 160 с.
  4. Лосский, В. Н. Богословское понятие человеческой личности / В. Н. Лосский // Боговидение. – Минск : Белорусский Экзархат – «Харвест», 2007. – С. 400 – 411.
  5. Несмелов, В. И. Наука о человеке/ В. И. Несмелов. – Санкт-Питербург : Общество памяти игумении Таисии, 2013. – 936 с.
  6. Окороков, В. Б. Трансформація західноєвропейської метафізики (онтологічний зріз): автореферат дисертації на здобуття наукового ступеня доктора філософських наук: 09.00.05/ Віктор Брониславович Окороков ; Дніпропетровський національний університет імені Олеся Гончара. – Дніпропетровськ, 2003.  – 42 с.
  7. Сигов, К. Проблема разрыва между онтологией и этикой в современных учениях о человеке /K. Сигов // «Православное учение о человеке». – Москва : Синоидальная Богословская Комиссия; Клин : Издательство «Христианская жизнь», 2004. – С. 340–356.
  8. Узланер, Д. Введение в постсекулярную философию / Д. Узланер // Логос. Постсекулярная философия. – 2011. – № 3(82). – С. 3–32.
  9. Balthasar, H. U. On the Concept of Person/ H. U. von Balthasar // Communio: International Catholic Review. – 1986. – № 13. – P. 18–26.
  10. Bartnik, C. S. Personalistic Ontology / C. S. Bartnik // Personalism. Science. Philosophy. Theology. – 2003. – №5. – P. 68–84.
  11. Bengtsson J. O. The Worldview of Personalism: Origins and Early Development / J. O. Bengtsson. – Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2011. – 320 p.
  12. Bowne, B. P. Personalism / B. P. Bowne. – Boston : Houghton Mifflin Company, 1908. – vi, 354 p.
  13. Bowne, B. P. Philosophy of Theism / B. P. Bowne. – Boston: Create Space Independent Publishing Platform, 2015. – 284 p.
  14. Brightman, E. S. Brightman. Personalism / E. S. Brightman // A History of Philosophical Systems [ed. by Vergilius Ferm]. – New York : Philosophical Library, 1950. – 343 p.
  15. Buford, T. O. Classical American Personalism [Electronic resource] / T. O. Buford. – Available at: – Title from the screen. – Accessed: 13.June.2016.
  16. Burrow, R. Personalism: A Critical Introduction / R. Burrow. – Saint Louis : Chalice Press, 1999. – 328 p.
  17. Clark, St. R. L. How many Selves make me?/ St. R. L.Clark// Human Being [Ed. by D.Cockburn] – Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991. – P. 67–92.
  18. Deats, P. The Boston Personalist Tradition in Philosophy, Social Ethics and Theology/ P. Deats, R. Carol. – Macon : Mercer University Press, 1986. – 254 p.
  19. Derrida, J. Writing and Difference/ J. Derrida. – London: Routledge, 2001. – 472 p.
  20. Flewelling, R. T. Studies in American Personalism / R. T. Flewelling // Personalism. Science. Philosophy. Theology: Biannual. – 2004. – №6. – P. 23–42.
  21. Foucault, M. Nietzsche, Genealogy, History / M. Foucault //Language, Counter-Memory, and Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews. – Oxford : Basil Blackwell, 1977. – P. 139–165.
  22. Foucault, M. The Subject and Power / M. Foucault // Michel Foucault : Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics [ed. by H. L. Dreyfus and P. Rabinow]. – Brighton : Harvester Press, 1982. – P. 208–227.
  23. Habermas, J. Religion ad Rationality: Essays on Reason, God and Modernity / J. Habermas, – Cambridge : MIT Press, 2002. – 384 p.
  24. Hocking, W. E. The Meaning of God in Human Experience [Electronic resource] / W. E. Hocking. – 1912. – Available at: – Title from the screen. – Accessed: 13.June.2016.
  25. Gacka, B. A. Presentation of Personalism [Electronic resource] / B. Gacka // Personalism: Science, Philosophy, Theology. – 2001. – Available at: – Title from the screen. – Accessed: 13.June.2016.
  26. Knudson, A. C. The Philosophy of Personalism/ A. C. Knudson. – New York : Abington, 1927. – 434 p.
  27. Mounier, E. Révolution personnaliste et communautaire [Electronic resource] / E. Mounier. – 2003. – Available at: – Title from the screen. – Accessed: 13.June.2016.
  28. Patsan, V. O. (Bishop Eulogius of Novomoskovsk). The Biblical Background of American Personalism/ V. O. Patsan (Bishop Eulogius of Novomoskovsk) // “Science and Society” : 8-th International Scientific and Practical Conference (23-30 March 2016). – London : Scieuro, 2016. – P. 120 – 132.
  29. Post-secular Philosophy: between Philisophy and Theology/ ed.: Ph. Blond. – London : Routledge, 1998. – 392 p.
  30. Williams, Th. D. Personalism [Electronic resource]/ Th. D. Williams, J. O. Bengtsson. – 2013. – Available at: – Title from the screen. – Accessed: 13.June.2016.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.